
Across the highlands
Madra
Chickpeas in a creamy, spiced yogurt sauce with ghee and whole spices
The dried seed pod of a ginger-family plant from the eastern Himalaya, smoked over an open fire. Large, wrinkled and dark brown, with a smoky, resinous, cooling aroma.
Black cardamom is the seed pod of Amomum subulatum, a relative of green cardamom grown mainly in Sikkim, Nepal and Bhutan. The pods are roughly the size of a thumbnail, ridged lengthwise, and dried over wood fires, which gives them their smoky flavour. The aroma is strong, smoky and earthy, with a cool, camphor-like edge; it has little in common with the sweet, floral freshness of green cardamom. It is usually used whole or lightly crushed in braises, lentils, rice and broths, where it can cook for a long time, and is removed before serving. It is sold in Indian and Asian grocers, sometimes in well-stocked spice shops, and by mail order; whole pods keep their aroma far longer than ground ones.
There is no truly equivalent substitute. A smaller amount of green cardamom provides the cardamom note but neither the smoke nor the heavy, camphor-like depth, and the dish turns lighter and more floral. Leaving it out entirely costs the dish some depth but keeps it coherent.

Across the highlands
Chickpeas in a creamy, spiced yogurt sauce with ghee and whole spices