
Across the highlands · 45 min hands-on · 8,2 h waiting · Vegetarian · Main course · For confident cooks
Madra
In German: Kichererbsen langsam in Joghurt geschmort
For 4 servings · US units
Chickpeas in a creamy, spiced yogurt sauce with ghee and whole spices
Madra comes from Himachal Pradesh, where it turns up on the table whenever there's something to celebrate. Tender chickpeas simmer slowly in yogurt until the sauce turns thick and glossy and smells of cinnamon, cloves and cardamom. Serve it with rice or roti and a humble bowl becomes a proper meal.
Ingredients
- 7 ozchickpeasdried, soaked overnight and boiled until tender
- 2½ cupsWaterfor cooking the chickpeas
- 15¾ ozYogurtfull-fat, whisked smooth
- 3 tbspfor tempering the spicesClarified butter, cooked until the water and milk solids separate out; nutty and suited to high heat.Substitute: Clarified butter replaces ghee readily, though it tastes milder. To make ghee yourself, simmer unsalted butter gently until the milk solids on the bottom turn light brown, then strain.Read more
- 1Cinnamonabout 3 cm
- 4Cloveswhole or roughly crushed
- 1black cardamomwhole
- 2green cardamomwhole
- 1bay leaves
- 1 tspCumin seedstempered in the fat
- 1 pinchDried resin from the root of a giant fennel-like plant, usually sold as a yellowish powder. Pungent and sulphurous raw, it turns mellow and onion- and garlic-like when fried in hot fat.Substitute: There is no true substitute. A little garlic and some onion fried in the fat point in the same direction but bring more sweetness and their own character, and they miss the point where hing is meant to replace onion and garlic; when in doubt, leave it out, and the dish will be flatter but not wrong.Read more
- 1 tspTurmeric
- 1½ tspcoriander
- 1 tspChilimild, for colour
- 1 tspA North Indian blend of toasted, ground spices such as cumin, coriander, cardamom, cinnamon, clove and black pepper, warm and fragrant rather than hot.Substitute: The best substitute is your own blend of toasted, freshly ground cumin and coriander seed with a little cardamom, cinnamon, clove and pepper; curry powder is not a replacement, as its turmeric and often fenugreek change the flavour and turn the dish yellow.Read more
- ½ tspCumin
- Saltto taste
- 1 tspfennel seedstempered with the whole spices (optional)
- 1 tbspwhisked into the yogurt to keep it from splitting (optional)Finely ground rice, gluten-free, used for batters, flatbreads and thickening.Substitute: In a pinch, you can grind rice finely yourself in a high-speed blender or spice grinder. Wheat flour makes batters chewier and less crisp, and it is not gluten-free.Read more
- almonds, raisins, grated coconutfor garnish, as desired (optional)
- fresh corianderfor garnish (optional)
Method
- Soak the chickpeasSoak the dried chickpeas overnight, about 8 hours, in plenty of water.
- Cook the chickpeas until tenderDrain the chickpeas, then cook them in fresh water with a little salt until tender (a pressure cooker works well) and drain them thoroughly.
- Get the yogurt readyWhisk the yogurt in a bowl until smooth. If you want extra insurance against it splitting later, whisk in the rice flour now.
- Toast the whole spicesHeat the ghee in a heavy pot. Add the cumin seeds, asafoetida, cinnamon stick, cloves, black and green cardamom and the Indian bay leaf, plus the fennel seeds if you're using them, and fry briefly until fragrant.
- Stir in the ground spicesStir in the turmeric, ground coriander, Kashmiri chili powder, garam masala and ground cumin, and let them toast for just a few seconds so nothing burns.
- Add the chickpeasAdd the cooked chickpeas and toss them well with the spices until every one is coated.
- Work in the yogurtTurn the heat right down and add the yogurt a little at a time, stirring constantly, so the sauce stays smooth.
- Simmer the sauce downLet everything simmer gently over low heat for 10 to 15 minutes, until the sauce thickens and the fat starts to separate at the edges.
- Season and serveRemove the Indian bay leaf and cinnamon stick. Season with salt, garnish with almonds, raisins, grated coconut and fresh coriander if you like, and serve with rice or roti.
Tips and variations
Kidney beans (rajma) or black-eyed peas are a good swap for the chickpeas. Some cooks reduce the yogurt in the fat first, stirring all the while, and only add the chickpeas afterwards; others simmer the whole spices along with the chickpeas while they cook. When you're short on time, a quick version with canned chickpeas, Greek yogurt and a little ginger does the job. Coconut oil or vegetable oil can stand in for the ghee. To serve, scatter over almonds, raisins and grated coconut if you like, and put out plenty of rice or warm roti alongside.
Allergens
Contains: Milk (including lactose)
May contain if you use the optional ingredients: Cereals containing gluten, Tree nuts, Sulphur dioxide and sulphites
Not every ingredient in this recipe has been checked, so nothing is promised as free from.
These notes follow from this recipe's ingredient list. Ready-made products and brands may contain further allergens — please check the packaging yourself.
Something not right?
This recipe was put together from independent sources and checked before publishing. Even so, a mistake can slip through — an amount that does not add up, a step that does not work as written. If you spot something, write to us: we will look into it and put it right.


