
Across the highlands · 40 min hands-on · 8,2 h waiting · Vegan · Main course · For confident cooks
Dubuk
In German: Huelsenfruchtpaste als Wintersuppe
For 4 servings · US units
Creamy Kumaoni horse gram soup with cumin, garlic and jimbu
Dubuk is a lentil dish from Kumaon: soaked horse gram is ground raw into a paste, then cooked down into a thick, creamy soup that gets its distinctive aroma from jimbu, a dried Himalayan herb. A bowl of it warms you right through on a winter day. Eat it with hot rice or, the traditional way, with roti made from finger millet.
Ingredients
- 7 ozhorse gram (gahat dal)soaked for 6–8 hours or overnight
- 3⅓ cupswaterto thin the paste, added gradually
- 2 tbspfor tempering; ghee as an alternativeCaution: Because of its erucic acid content, some mustard oil is labelled for external use only, so for cooking use only oil that is explicitly sold as edible.Cold-pressed oil from brown or yellow mustard seeds, golden to amber, with a sharp, pungent smell.Substitute: Rapeseed or canola oil comes from the same plant family and works as a base; a little mustard powder or freshly ground brown mustard seed brings back some of the heat. The characteristic pungent bite and full aroma, especially in pickles, cannot be matched this way.Read more
- 1 tspTurmeric
- 1 tspChili powder
- 1 tspSaltadjust to taste
- 1 tspcumintoasted in the hot fat
- 4 clovesGarlicfinely chopped, sautéed in the oil
- 1Tomatochopped
- ½ ozfresh corianderchopped, for garnish
- 1 tsptoasted in the fat for the characteristic aroma (optional)A dried herb from a wild allium of the Nepali highlands, fried in fat to give lentil dishes a mild, oniony, garlicky aroma.Substitute: There is no true equivalent, but dried chives briefly fried in ghee with a small pinch of finely chopped garlic point in the right direction. What is missing is the earthy, faintly smoky depth of the herb, and garlic easily takes over, so use it sparingly.Read more
- toasted in the fat (optional)Dried resin from the root of a giant fennel-like plant, usually sold as a yellowish powder. Pungent and sulphurous raw, it turns mellow and onion- and garlic-like when fried in hot fat.Substitute: There is no true substitute. A little garlic and some onion fried in the fat point in the same direction but bring more sweetness and their own character, and they miss the point where hing is meant to replace onion and garlic; when in doubt, leave it out, and the dish will be flatter but not wrong.Read more
- 3½ ozonionfinely chopped, fried golden (optional)
- ½ ozgingergrated (optional)
- ½ tsplet them pop in the fat (optional)The small brown or black mustard seeds used in Himalayan cooking are sold in Asian and Indian grocers, while the yellow seeds found in ordinary supermarkets are milder.Substitute: Yellow mustard seeds will do at a pinch, but they taste milder and less pungent, so use a little more.Read more
- Riceground to a paste, for thickening (optional)
Method
- Soak the horse gramRinse the horse gram well, cover it with plenty of water and leave it to soak for 6–8 hours or overnight.
- Grind into a pasteDrain the horse gram and blend it with a small splash of the water into a fine, smooth paste.
- Toast the spicesHeat the oil in a heavy-bottomed pot. Add the cumin and, if you like, the mustard seeds and let them pop, then, if you have them, briefly toast the jimbu and a pinch of asafoetida. If you're using onion, fry it golden now; finish with the garlic and, if you like, the ginger, cooking just until fragrant.
- Fry the pasteAdd the horse gram paste to the pot and fry it for a few minutes, stirring constantly so it doesn't catch on the bottom.
- Whisk in the waterPour in the remaining water a little at a time, stirring without stopping, until you have a smooth soup with no lumps.
- Season and thickenStir in the turmeric, chili powder, salt and chopped tomato. If you want the soup a bit thicker, stir in some rice paste at this point.
- Simmer gentlyLet the dubuk simmer over low heat for about 20 minutes, stirring now and then, until it's thick and creamy. Taste at the end and add more salt if needed.
- Garnish and serveScatter over the chopped fresh coriander and serve hot with rice.
Tips and variations
You can use ghee instead of the oil for the tempering. Pigeon peas (tur/arhar dal) also work in place of horse gram. For a chunkier version, cook the soaked horse gram soft in a pressure cooker, mash it roughly and simmer it with a masala of onion, ginger, garlic, green chili, tomato and coriander seeds. To make it more of an occasion, deep-fry half the paste as small pakoras, soak them briefly and add them to the soup at the end, then pour over a tempering of ghee, cumin, mustard seeds and dried chili. And instead of rice, serve it with mandua roti made from finger millet, the traditional flatbread to eat with dubuk in Kumaon.
Allergens
Contains: Mustard
Not every ingredient in this recipe has been checked, so nothing is promised as free from.
These notes follow from this recipe's ingredient list. Ready-made products and brands may contain further allergens — please check the packaging yourself.
Something not right?
This recipe was put together from independent sources and checked before publishing. Even so, a mistake can slip through — an amount that does not add up, a step that does not work as written. If you spot something, write to us: we will look into it and put it right.


